Key Takeaways
The alcoholic beverage industry is facing meaningful changes, and we believe the current cyclicality may be hiding deeper structural issues
Consumer tastes are changing, with young adults in the US drinking less–driven primarily by health concerns–which may have a lasting effect on volumes as this cohort ages
Certain brands may have priced too aggressively in recent years, opening a price gap that will be difficult to close and lastly, heavily skewed consumption, GLP-1s, and regulatory risks may be underappreciated reasons for caution
The pandemic-induced alcohol super-cycle has left the industry dealing with a hangover that producers are struggling to work through. After sales skyrocketed in 2021-2022 due to lockdowns, shifting consumer spend, and price increases, 2023 was a challenging year marked by weaker volumes that left investors wondering, is this a temporary headache or a warning sign of deeper structural change? We think there is a compelling case for the latter, and hence we are being very selective within the sector, especially in developed markets. Beer shipments faced their worst year since 1999, while spirits are looking wobbly after having leaned excessively on price and mix to support moderating volumes.1 Despite relying on price/mix to drive growth, spirits continue to trade at near-market multiples. Therefore, we think that investors may be too complacent with regard to the growth outlook. We’ve touched on this topic before – in 2016 we published a whitepaper titled Do Multiples Matter? in which we argued that “that growth and value are joined at the hip”, and that therefore investors needed to expect higher growth from higher-multiple stocks. Here, we revisit the topic of slowing growth and multiple risk as it relates to alcoholic beverages, and specifically spirits.
Organic Sales Growth Has Been Unsustainably High
Multiple Compression Risk: Parallels to Tobacco
The multiple risk concerns are not without precedent. We see a clear parallel to tobacco stocks, which de-rated significantly around 2017. Interestingly, investors had previously been comfortable with the similar tobacco model of relying on price/mix, despite falling volumes. Global cigarette volumes, ex-China, have been declining since 2008, but the de-rating in tobacco only occurred in 2017 – nine years later – on the back of increased regulatory scrutiny and accelerating volume declines from reduced risk products.2 We believe spirits face similar risks. Notably, there are important pricing power advantages in tobacco, which still could not save the category. First, the average selling price for a pack of cigarettes is much lower than that of alcohol, meaning that buyers are less sensitive to an illustrative 10% price increase due to the lower absolute change in price. Relatedly, we think large spirit distillers may have increased prices too aggressively in recent years, thus accidentally promoting trade-downs. For example, a bottle of Casamigos Blanco is now priced around $50 in New York, relative to Espolon Blanco, another 100% agave offering, at $25. There are no such savings to be found when trading down in tobacco given the average pack costs roughly $10 in the US, and therefore savings from downtrading will be comparatively small. This is a structural issue because consumers who trade down may never go back to the $50 bottle, given the broadly similar quality and attributes of these products.
Forward Multiples Over Time
Shifting Demographic Trends
Share of US 18- to-34-Year-Olds Who Drink
The decline in alcohol volumes is well known and even producers will admit that people drink less but better over time, industry parlance for positive mix. However, there are now a host of potential reasons for accelerated volume declines, such as demographic factors, changing tastes and increased awareness of negative health impacts. Gallup polls have found that 18- to 34-year-olds in the US have become increasing less likely to drink alcohol, with the percent who drink having fallen from 72% two decades ago to 62% in 2023. Further, they found that the percentage of young adults saying they ever drink, that they drank in the past week, or that they sometimes drink more than they should are all lower today. Said differently, fewer young adults are drinking, they drink less frequently, and when they do, they consume less. Health concerns appear to be a driving factor, with 52% now believing that even moderate drinking is unhealthy, up from 34% five years ago. This belief is likely to be structural and may accelerate volume declines, given that our understanding of the health impacts is only likely to increase, driving further aversion from this cohort and future potential consumers.
Beer: Back to 1999 (Volumes)
In addition to there being fewer drinkers, people are drinking differently. There has been an ongoing trend away from beer and towards spirits in the US. This share of consumption gain partially explains the difference in multiples between beer and spirits. However, the shift away from beer seems to be accelerating, with US beer shipments falling more than 5% in the first nine months of 2023. Full year shipments are expected to hit their lowest level since 1999, according to industry tracker Beer Marketer’s Insights.1 While traditional beer sales are flat-to-declining, non-alcoholic beer sales are on the rise, having averaged ~30% growth in dollar-terms annually in the US over the past four years, according to NielsenIQ.3
US Market Share By Supplier Revenue (%)
Spirits: Growth Engine is Stalling
Despite the share gains and price/mix benefits in spirits, there is also reason for caution. Distillers may have increased prices too aggressively in key categories. For example, the tequila category, a key growth driver in recent years, is broadening out, with sales increasingly driven by lower-price point offerings, as opposed to the super-premium. This may foreshadow the end of the super-premium tequila boom, in which case distillers will be left looking for the next leg of growth. Even beyond tequila, weak consumer demand for high end premium and super-premium priced liquors was cited by the Distilled Spirits Council of the US as the key factor behind slow US spirits sales last year. Total spirit sales in 2023 were largely flat, and increases were driven by the lower-end categories with a notable decline in super-premium (see chart below). The US market is particularly important because it represents an outsized share of profits due to the higher average prices and margins compared to other countries, hence the focus on it in this report. At Diageo, for example, the US represents 40% of sales but almost 60% of EBIT, given the country’s 38% margin is materially higher than the Group margin of 27%. Hence, a pullback in US premiumization raises questions about whether distillers’ primary growth engine is stalling.
US Spirits Premiumization Stalls
Skewed Consumption and Potential GLP-1 Risk
Further, an underappreciated risk is that alcohol consumption is heavily skewed by the right-tail of heavy drinkers. A study by the National Institute of Health (NIH) and economist Philip J. Cook, revealed that 60 percent of Americans aged 18 and over consume half a drink or less a week, while the top 10% of drinkers, who consume 74 drinks per week, account for more than half of all alcohol consumed in the U.S.4 There is a clear concentration risk in this segment of drinkers, and according to Cook, “…the heaviest drinkers are of greatly disproportionate importance to the sales and profitability of the alcoholic beverage industry. If the top decile could be induced to curb their consumption to that of the next lower group (the ninth decile) then total ethanol sales would fall by 60%.” Additionally, although not yet present in the numbers, GLP-1s may compound this issue. GLP-1s have been shown to reduce alcohol consumption in animals, and a study recently published in Nature claims to provide, “initial real-world evidence of reduced alcohol consumption in people with obesity taking Semaglutide or Tirzepatide medications”.5 Although we are in the early innings of understanding (never mind mass producing and distributing) GLP-1s, this could present another headwind to alcohol consumption over the long-term.
Drinks Per Week By Decile
Regulatory Headwinds Reinforce Tobacco Parallels
Regulatory Threats on the Horizon
Labelling Restrictions Reminiscent of Tobacco
Source: Clipping of The Irish Times headline detailing the new labelling laws. TheIrishTimes.com, May 22, 2023.
Lastly, new regulatory announcements in Ireland are an unprecedented negative for the industry. Ireland will soon become the first country in the world to mandate comprehensive health labelling on alcoholic drinks. Starting in 2026, all alcoholic drinks’ labels will need to state risks of cancer and liver disease associated with consuming the products, along with calorie count, grams of alcohol, and dangers of drinking while pregnant. Coldiretti, Italy’s biggest farmers’ association, described the “terrifying” warnings as a “direct attack”, per the Guardian.6 Labelling restrictions are tobacco-esque and don’t bode well for future developments. Conceptually, the end-state of alcohol packaging resembling cigarettes’, with prominent health labelling, would be especially negative from a price/mix perspective given the brand appeal of certain alcoholic categories. For example, picture super-premium spirits without the branding. Circling back to the tobacco parallel, increased regulatory scrutiny precipitated the de-rating, and these regulations show that alcohol is not immune to negative regulatory developments.
Summary
In summary, alcoholic beverages are faced with the potential for accelerated demand destruction, slowing premiumization, right-tail risks from heavy drinkers and GLP-1s, and increased regulations. As investors, we are looking for asymmetric upside opportunities, and we think the market may be too complacent on the outlook for spirits, which is reflected in their near-market multiples despite the litany of risks presented above and the clear parallels to tobacco. With that said, we continue to look for selective opportunities as there are always some who can figure out ways to grow.
END NOTES
1 “Beer Faced Declines in 2023.”, NACS , January 2, 2024.
2“Does the Drink Industry Have an ESG Alcohol Problem?”, Jefferies, March 2021.
3Black, Aaron. “Sobriety Is In, and Nonalcoholic Beer Sales Are Soaring.”, Wall Street Journal, October 12, 2023.
4Haden, Jeff. “How much do the top 10 percent drink?”, Inc., October 7, 2014.
5Quddos, F., Hubshman, Z., Tegge, A. et al. “Semaglutide and Tirzepatide reduce alcohol consumption in individuals with obesity”, Nature, Sci Rep 13, November 28, 2023.
6“Ireland to introduce world-first alcohol health labelling policy”, The Guardian , May 2023.
IMORTANT INFORMATION
The information provided in this document does not constitute investment advice and no investment decision should be made based on it. Neither the information contained in this document or in any accompanying oral presentation is a recommendation to follow any strategy or allocation. In addition, neither is a recommendation, offer or solicitation to sell or buy any security or to purchase of shares in any fund or establish any separately managed account. It should not be assumed that any investments made by GQG Partners LLC (GQG) in the future will be profitable or will equal the performance of any securities discussed herein. Before making any investment decision, you should seek expert, professional advice, including tax advice, and obtain information regarding the legal, fiscal, regulatory and foreign currency requirements for any investment according to the law of your home country, place of residence or current abode.
This document reflects the views of GQG as of a particular time. GQG’s views may change without notice. Any forward-looking statements or forecasts are based on assumptions and actual results may vary. GQG provides this information for informational purposes only. GQG has gathered the information in good faith from sources it believes to be reliable, including its own resources and third parties. However, GQG does not represent or warrant that any information, including, without limitation, any past performance results and any third-party information provided, is accurate, reliable or complete, and it should not be relied upon as such. GQG has not independently verified any information used or presented that is derived from third parties, which is subject to change. Information on holdings, allocations, and other characteristics is for illustrative purposes only and may not be representative of current or future investments or allocations.
Past performance may not be indicative of future results. Performance may vary substantially from year to year or even from month to month. The value of investments can go down as well as up. Future performance may be lower or higher than the performance presented and may include the possibility of loss of principal. It should not be assumed that investments made in the future will be profitable or will equal the performance of securities listed herein.
The information contained in this document is unaudited. It is published for the assistance of recipients, but is not to be relied upon as authoritative and is not to be substituted for the exercise of one’s own judgment. GQG is not required to update the information contained in these materials, unless otherwise required by applicable law. No portion of this document and/or its attachments may be reproduced, quoted or distributed without the prior written consent of GQG.
GQG is registered as an investment adviser with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Please see GQG’s Form ADV Part 2, which is available upon request, for more information about GQG.
Any account or fund advised by GQG involves significant risks and is appropriate only for those persons who can bear the economic risk of the complete loss of their investment. There is no assurance that any account or fund will achieve its investment objectives. Accounts and funds are subject to price volatility and the value of a portfolio will change as the prices of investments go up or down. Before investing in a strategy, you should consider the risks of the strategy as well as whether the strategy is appropriate based upon your investment objectives and risk tolerance.
There may be additional risks associated with international and emerging markets investing involving foreign, economic, political, monetary, and/or legal factors. International investing is not for everyone. You can lose money by investing in securities.
Where referenced, the title Partner for an employee of GQG Partners LLC indicates the individual’s leadership status within the organization. While Partners hold equity interests in GQG Partners Inc., as a legal matter they do not hold partnership interests in GQG Partners LLC or GQG Partners Inc.
GQG Partners LLC is a wholly owned subsidiary of GQG Partners Inc., a Delaware corporation that is listed on the Australian Securities Exchange.
NOTICE TO AUSTRALIA & NEW ZEALAND INVESTORS
The information in this document is issued and approved by GQG Partners LLC (“GQG”), a limited liability company and authorised representative of GQG Partners (Australia) Pty Ltd, ACN 626 132 572, AFSL number 515673. This information and our services may only be provided to retail and wholesale clients (as defined in section 761G of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)) domiciled in Australia. This document contains general information only, does not contain any personal advice and does not take into account any prospective investor’s objectives, financial situation or needs. In New Zealand, any offer of a Fund is limited to ‘wholesale investors’ within the meaning of clause 3(2) of Schedule 1 of the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013. This information is not intended to be dis-tributed or passed on, directly or indirectly, to any other class of persons in Australia and New Zealand, or to persons outside of Australia and New Zealand.
NOTICE TO CANADIAN INVESTORS
This document has been prepared solely for information purposes and is not an offering memorandum nor any other kind of an offer to buy or sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy or sell any security, instrument or investment product or to participate in any particular trading strategy. It is not intended and should not be taken as any form of advertising, recommendation or investment advice. This information is confidential and for the use of the intended recipients only. The distribution of this document in Canada is restricted to recipients in certain Canadian jurisdictions who are eligible “permitted clients” for purposes of National Instrument 31-103 Registration Requirements, Exemptions and Ongoing Registrant Obligations.
NOTICE TO SOUTH AFRICAN INVESTORS
Investors should take cognisance of the fact that there are risks involved in buying or selling any financial product. Past performance of a financial product is not necessarily indicative of future performance. The value of financial products can increase as well as decrease over time, depending on the value of the underlying securities and market conditions. The investment value of a financial product is not guaranteed and any Illustrations, forecasts or hypothetical data are not guaranteed, these are provided for illustrative purposes only. This document does not constitute a solicitation, invitation or investment recommendation. Prior to selecting a financial product or fund it is recommended that South Africa based investors seek specialised financial, legal and tax advice. GQG PARTNERS LLC is a licensed financial services provider with the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) of the Republic of South Africa, with FSP number 48881.
NOTICE TO UNITED KINGDOM INVESTORS
GQG Partners is not an authorised person for the purposes of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 of the United Kingdom (“FSMA”) and the distribution of this document in the United Kingdom is restricted by law. Accordingly, this document is provided only for and is directed only at persons in the United Kingdom reasonably believed to be of a kind to whom such promotions may be communicated by a person who is not an authorised person under FSMA pursuant to the FSMA (Financial Promotion) Order 2005 (the “FPO”). Such persons include: (a) persons having professional experience in matters relating to investments; and (b) high net worth bodies corporate, partnerships, unincorporated associations, trusts, etc. falling within Article 49 of the FPO. The services provided by GQG Partners and the investment opportunities described in this document are available only to such persons, and persons of any other description may not rely on the information in it. All, or most, of the rules made under the FSMA for the protection of retail clients will not apply, and compensation under the United Kingdom Financial Services Compensation Scheme will not be available.
GQG Partners (UK) Ltd. is a company registered in England and Wales, registered number 1175684. GQG Partners (UK) Ltd. is an appointed representative of Sapia Partners LLP, which is a firm authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (“FCA”) (550103).
© 2024 GQG Partners LLC. All rights reserved. This document reflects the views of GQG as of April 2024.
TL ALCHL 0424